Amber ~ have you ensured that your phone and your AppleTV are on the same WiFi network? I believe AirPlay will not work otherwise, for example, if you phone is on a cellular data network and your AppleTV is using WiFi.
I'm also having this problem of not seeing the airplay icon. I have an Apple TV (2nd gen) and an iPhone 5s, and an iPad-mini. They are also all sharing the same wifi network.
(Edited by Moderator - Alex Parsons
on April 1, 2022)
Amelia ~ The devices you list should all be compatible with the AirPlay feature. Here are instructions from Apple on how to troubleshoot not seeing the airplay icon in the control center. If you need any additional assistance, please email us at support@pilatesanytime.com
I'm not showing an airplay icon show up on my phone - i have the most updated software and a brand new apple TV - please let me know.
Thanks!
Amber