Documentary #6543

Pilates Returns to Life | Episode 2

20 min - Documentary
1 like
No comments yet

Description

The story he told was legendary. The truth was even stranger.

In Episode 2 of this 4 part documentary series, discover what truly happened in Joe Pilates' journey, from the Isle of Man to a ship bound for New York. Follow the trail of patents and boxing rings, and enjoy warm stories from a Pilates insider who knew Joe as a friend.
What You'll Need: No props needed

About This Video

(Pace N/A)
Nov 22, 2026
(Log In to track)

Transcript

Read Full Transcript

Joe was absolutely totally obsessed, single-minded about Contrology in many ways. I mean, not only as a mechanism for saving the world and saving everyone's health, and of curing every illness that ever existed and the ability to fix broken legs. Anything that could be done with your body, somehow Joe believes that Contrology could do it. When he went to England, he had left behind his children, and maybe his first wife. This is a complicated thing, it hasn't been possible to work it out yet when exactly he left.

On your end to England? Very little is known about Joe's initial time in England. According to Joe, he worked in a circus, boxed professionally, and even trained the police. Maybe he did. But whatever life Joe imagined for himself in England was about to be in erupted by something much bigger than him. In August 1914, England declared war and quickly enacted the mandatory detention of enemy borne male civilians from nations fighting against the allied powers. Joe would have lived in Blackpool, a major seaside resort and entertainment hub.

This is where he was likely arrested. He was sent for a couple of months to, internment camp in Lancaster. And from there, he was brought to the Isle Of Man. Joe was 31 years old when he was transferred to the Isle Of Man. And it was here behind barbed wire that one of the biggest legends in Pilates history was supposedly born. Living on the Isle Of Man has really given me such a strong interest in looking into the history of Joseph Pilates.

He spent three and a half years of his life here during World War one from September 1915 through to March 1919. Soon after I'd started learning Pilates myself, I found out my great grandfather there was also interned at Nakalo Camp on the Isle Of Man. And in fact, the deep fry dug into the history of the camp, and looked at information. I found out amazingly my great grandfather was interned in the same sub campus, Joseph Clark, 90s. It was very well known at the time.

Barb wire psychosis was a major issue for civilian attorneys in particular. Through lack of movement, people were falling into despair and the... Everything was done to try and help alleviate the boredom and give these attorneys something to do. It's interesting as well. The Jorgen Mueller system was very much prevalent to Nokehlo, and paling the Swedish physical cultureist to very much predated Joseph Lardi's and Jorgen Mueller. His gymnastic free exercises were very much performed.

It's just your own body weight. And in fact just days after Joseph parties arrived at Mikaela, there was a mass demonstration of gymnastic free exercises that no doubt Joseph parties would have been in the crowds watching as they performed. That camp at Mikaela started to grow and grow. Eventually, it housed 23,000 men at any one time. Overall, the period, during the period of whole war, more over 30,000 men passed through the gates. And a lot of the attorneys obviously had been working in... Sorry about the cat.

They did have cats in Nokia, obviously, which inspired Joseph Pilates. I heard, like, three different stories about why the influenza epidemic never reached Islam Man. When I was at Iowa Man, and I was asking questions about that, I heard the story that Joe Pilates had a bunch of people that he was working with and nobody got flu during the epidemic. And the lady nodded her head. And then she said, well, you know, This is the deal.

The Island man is in the middle of the Irish Sea. We have tons and tons of fresh air here, and it turned out that hardly anybody here got the flu. So so that was the story. And then, and that's probably more of the evidence. It probably just happened that, you know, he was really lucky one of the attorneys who kept diaries at the time.

He writes that the fields above Nocsello, the recreation fields. That was the birthplace of German boxing. Nocsello Joseph Plates did referee a box in March. That's a matter of official record in one of the camp newspapers. I actually do have some insights into this because, into, like, how... When you started developing, like, controls, you're the body's method. Originally, you know, people said, well, he was at Iowa Man, he was interned and working with bed springs with patients. That's when he developed the equipment that later become the reformer and the Cadillac and all this other stuff. But as far as the reformer's concerned, he patented the reformer about in the early twenties.

It was while he was in Germany. So there'd be no real reason for him to have developed that into into... While he was in an internment camp, he would've had a lot of time to think about stuff. And my guess is that he was probably thinking about this sooner, about condition And he probably developed the reformer either right after isle a man. He might have thought about it, but, you know, the the the idea that he used bed springs is kind of a joke because of bed spring, you know, it's only about this long.

And it only extends about this far. Right? So, you know, the idea of using a bed spring for a Cadillac or a reformer is just to me, it's just kind of kind of silly. This argument of whether he did or didn't create a reformer there or if a youth brings there. There's no actual evidence of Joseph Pilates saying he did that. I don't know why so many people want to try and disprove the fact that he used Springs when there's no clear evidence that he ever said he did.

I have my theory about it, that's, that the first patent, but at least one of the first patents that he patented was the food corrector. So maybe the springs that you need for a food character are the ones out of, of a bed. So maybe that could be something that he did. The longer springs, as far as I understood, appeared when he moved to The US, And I think that the main, source for that is that he needed to save space because the original, reformer patent with the weight were definitely too big and he wanted to have something smaller. Now we know that the springs are a key thing for the Pilates experience, but probably in those days, to him, springs were just a way to save space. And to have, mostly the same result.

So this entrenchment became a turning point in his life, and and he found, his colleague. And after he returned to Germany, he never, said he was a brewer So in his, registration cards, it's always a sports teacher. So he had, yeah, he had found in his profession. The odd thing in my early career with Pilates was that we established a relationship outside of the gym. So when Clara asked me, which was completely out of the blue one after, one morning, would I come and have a beer with with Joe I again nodded my head and said, sure. And then kept wondering, well, what am I doing? I mean, he's my, my, my trainer, my physical guy.

What am I having a beer, and, was very uncomfortable. We hardly had anything to talk about. And so we established this social contact. That's all I can really call it right now. Why did he do this? Why was he even interested in me? But he did.

There was a lot of time of contact. He liked to take walks with me. He liked go to the park with me, but I never saw anyone else in the apartment. I never spoke to anyone else who went there. My parents never were in it.

So in some ways, you know, it it was a unique a relationship. When Yosfelaris came back after he was interned, he went back to Germany, so he had to go back. All the inmates, were forced, to go back to Germany. He came back to the city where he had lived before he went to England to Geising. And there, he set up a boxing school.

When Joe returned to Galgent, he was 35 years old. Over five years had passed since he was last in Germany, He rents an apartment and his daughter Laney, who is now 14 years old, comes back to live with him. She had been living with Joe's father. Wilhelme, Joe's adopted son, stayed with his maternal grandmother, and Joe became estranged from him. Later that year, Joe Marries his second wife, Alfreda Latemann, who was a widow with a 16 year old daughter, Carola.

Joe, Alfreda, Laney, and Carola, all lived together. And within short time, Joe had his second family. Now when Joe moved back and started his boxing school, he did so with his younger brother, Fred, who he reconnected with. So this boxing scene was new because before the first world war, boxing had been banned in Germany. It was not allowed to do public boxing events.

And this was only possible after the war because Pilates became part of a really new thing, and I think that was been exciting. He was almost 40 when when he was stepping into the ring with opponents were much younger and he still lasted 10 rounds. So he was extremely fit at at that time. Joseph Pilates had a glass eye and he told different stories about how how he lost his eye and and about when he when that happened. And I was not able to verify, any of these versions.

All we can say is that he had it before he was interned on the out of man because there's this picture of him sitting at the table in one of the barracks, and he already has a glass eye. So it must have happened before that. And his boxing career started after he came back from Nakalo. He wouldn't have lost the aid during one of his professional fights, but he might have participated in fights earlier might have been a boxing match or might have happened, in his youth. One of the main missing link in a pilatus history, but in the movement culture history is, movement started in the in the West. In those years, not as a, healthy thing, not about health, but mainly about performance.

So it's pretty strange because today, we use the adjective, performative. But probably also in those days, we can use the objective performative. Joe was performative before all his life. He tried all his life to be something or someone he was not able to be. So the boxing thing was a thing because he was not a good boxer, probably.

He so went to another route that was not more on the true boxing, but more on the boxing performances. So, like, public fights that entertain people more than, real athletic boxing. If you compare him to many other people in the same time and same days, you see that it was a pattern, very typical pattern, especially for male European people. Learning that help us to get beyond the mask he tried to have to create about himself and, learn about the man which is fragile personality probably. Think about the island man moment in his life. We spent so much time talking about what he did there, but one thing that we can absolutely be sure about is that in those days, he was being in his body, being aware of his body, training his body was a way to have a better mental health. We can understand that only if we put him in the context.

We stop saying that he is an absolute genius that wake up one day and, create everything out of nothing. But, we can understand that he was a part of a bigger history that's, that's a worldwide culture. And then he was influenced by some of them, he changed some of them, and we can also appreciate more what he did compared to other people. JP Mueller was a incredible person who was very wealthy at the time. He created a method.

He called my system. He wrote the book at the turning of the century. Probably Joe read it because if we take that book and we, see the exercises, we see the format that JP Mueller created, Joe created something very similar, while at least tried to create something very similar when he wrote return to life. Another model was Eugene Sando. Many people knows from other environments like body building and things like that.

There's a lot of things in, the books of Eugene Sendos that can be really copy and pasted to Joe's books, if you look at the life story of Eugene Sando, we can see a lot of, commonalities with the Joe's life. Sometimes, I believe the things like the legend that Joe worked for circus when he moved to England. We don't know if Joe did it, but we know for sure that Eugene Sendham did it. Probably Joe took pieces of other people's life and brought his life, to his invented past, just to appear more appealing. In addition to coaching boxing, Joe advertised himself teaching wrestling, self defense, fencing, and weight lifting.

In 1922, at 38 years of age, Joe was granted his first patent for the foot corrector, which he applied for a few years earlier. It's not clear when he invented it, but at this time, Germany was in a post World War one economical by 1923, Joe's boxing school business had failed, and it is assumed that he was having marital troubles as he separated from Elfried and moved to Hamburg, alone, again, leaving the children in Galton it. While in Hamburg, in 1923, Joe Pilates began another life changing turning point. A couple of really cool things about the whole story of how he got here that I thought were really fascinating. That that made me ask a lot more questions, and, of course, I have no answer for most of them.

Is when he filed his patents in The United States, I thought at one point that it was all the patents that he filed, but he actually filed patents in The UK and in Germany. And I think even in France, on the reformer. When he developed or invented the reformer, he actually knew it was gonna go big. And he knew that he was gonna be selling it in Europe, and he knew he was gonna be selling it in The United States. Getting a patent back then as is now, it's not a cheap thing.

So you don't just do it on a whim. You know, you've gotta paid lawyers. You gotta pay lawyers in foreign countries to file these patents. It's a big deal, but he did it somehow. And then when you juxtaposition that on the fact that when he came to The United States, he made two trips within thirteen months. And I heard actually one of those trips was probably business class.

But to be able to do it, even to make one trip, basically steerage house, was equal to about six months with the wages in Germany. To make two trips, I meant, okay, so now he's patent this device in different you know, different countries. And now he comes to United Pilates, probably need to do reconnaissance to see what's out there. Then he goes back, and then he comes back again. And at that time, he brings Clara, which is another controversy, but we'll leave that one alone for right now. And then they move right to 9 39th 8th Avenue.

And and you think, okay. So here's a guy. He's filing patents in different different countries. He makes two trips to The United States within thirteen months. The guy's got a plan. When he went to The United States in 1926, he left behind his second wife, who took care of, he was a FedEx's daughter from his first marriage and her own daughter, but, they were almost, adults.

When he was making some important steps in his life. There was this other side to it that he was leaving people behind, and and it was... He was really sort of sacrificing his families in order to start a new life. April 1926. At the age of 42, Joe boards the ship west failure and emigrates permanently to The US. But how did he do it? You have to have, like, two witnesses that will kind of vouch for your credibility and say this this is a good guy.

We think that he qualifies to be, you know, assist in The United States. There were two people that signed that document for him. One was a guy named Charles Tririer. And I got really excited because I thought maybe he's related to Corolla Trier. Turns out not so much. But the other guy was a guy named Nathaniel Fletcher, and it turns out that that guy was the publisher ring magazine. Ring magazine was the first magazine that actually kept boxing statistics in The United States.

Nate Fletcher was actually a boxing promoter too. And his office was right around the corner from nine from Joseph Pilates. Although I haven't found any direct correlation, I'm kind of thinking that maybe Nate Fletcher from ring magazine sponsored Joe to come over on the second trip and maybe gave him some money. From what I... What we can see is he moved... Came basically off the boat and his first address that we can find is 930, 90th Avenue.

And so he moved right there. How did he have all that stuff lined up? And by the way, at that point, that cleared us too. So they supposedly met on the boat, and then they came moving together at 09:30, ninetieth Avenue. And the second part of his life, Yos Pilates, Clara. They were this, couple, and in the first part of his life, Yos pilatus was always changing. He was, changing where he lived. He was changing his profession.

He was changing his wives. So there was no stability of any kind. And then after he came to New York, he stayed there. He he was living in the same place. He was working at the same studio, and he was living the same woman. Whether or not, they were actually married.

I cannot say because I I didn't find a marriage certificate. I actually don't even know at what point in Joe's life that Clara changed her name to Pilates, because most of the stuff that I see written out illegal documents is Clara Zooner. And that's something called immigration stuff, and citizenship stuff. It does say what her occupation is. She's the assistant director of physical culture. That's her that's her job.

The only thing I see is on Christmas cards. Sometimes, you'll see Joan Clare Pilates, but you don't see anything on anything legal. He was a Pilates brother Fred or his full name was Clement Fish Pilates, and he had emigrated to United States, three years before Gills Plattista, and he settled on some fluids with his family. He was a bit different, than his brother because he didn't leave his family behind. He, invited them to join him after he had, established himself He was an important person for Joseph Pilatus. They had been close. Before they went to America as brothers, they had both enthusiastic gymnasts.

They were both involved in the boxing school. And when they were both living in in The United States, they were still meeting. There are some videos of them, doing some funny fights together. And they were also trying to collaborate selling equipment or filling up equipment. So we think their relationship was closed, but there was a huge distance between New York and Saint Louis. So why do we not speak so much about, Fred Pilates today?

I think it was because of that. You know, he was not, he was not in New York. And after Joseph Pilates died, there there was no connection anymore. I haven't really done that much work to find find survivors or Pilates family's members. Yet, there was a a lady that lived with Joe Joe... Lived in the same building as Claire Pilates named Hannah, who who may have shown up at Clara's funeral, but don't know about that. Then there was Mary Pilates.

Mary Pilates was Joe's brother's Fred, his daughter. He was a collapsed and a second wife. They divorced. After he had gone to United States, he was keeping in touch with his daughter, Laney. She was also visiting him. New York. And after the second World War, he sent her food and and and clothes and presents. Joe wasted no time when he set foot in New York City, and he would spend the rest of his life, perfecting not only a method, but a story about the man who created it.

And that story was about to begin.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

You need to be a subscriber to post a comment.

Please Log In or Create an Account to start your free trial.

Footer Pilates Anytime Logo

Welcome to Your Pilates Era

Experience Your Joy

Let's Begin